Divine Innovation

Share this post

[39.0] living a lie through AI

divineinnovation.substack.com

[39.0] living a lie through AI

dreaming of other worlds in a multiple-choice setting

Sep 4, 2022
Share

I’ve been working a lot the past few weeks with the windows of my apartment wide open, which, most of the time, is a splendid and nearly pastoral experience smack dab in the middle of Seattle. Blue heron squawking, crows babbling (I like them, especially since I learned they hold grudges), wind whooshing, and so forth. But then a car drives by and ruins the whole experience! Rubber hits road and makes loud noises; truck hits bump and its tow makes jingly jingly sounds. 

In the midst of one of those acoustic unpleasantries I was scrolling Twitter, as is my wont, and came across the account @betterstreetsai. Using DALL-E, the image-generating AI platform, the @betterstreetsai account’s creator, NYC-based artist Zach Katz, generates photorealistic alternatives to existing, car-centric spaces across the world. I let out a deep sigh upon seeing cityscapes stripped of vehicles. 

Ever been to Boston? Imagine Storrow Drive looking like this (and not getting hit by a car while biking to your summer internship in 2016, xoxo!)

Twitter avatar for @betterstreetsai
AI-generated street transformations @betterstreetsai
Storrow Drive (Boston, Massachusetts)
Image
Image
3:00 PM ∙ Aug 16, 2022
2,642Likes222Retweets

Or like, holy shit, Atlantic Ave in Brooklyn not just being a high-octane clusterfuck?

Twitter avatar for @betterstreetsai
AI-generated street transformations @betterstreetsai
Atlantic Ave (Brooklyn, New York)
Image
Image
10:20 PM ∙ Aug 22, 2022
391Likes25Retweets

And if you’ve ever been to Pike Place Market in Seattle: What if dangerously tall pickups couldn’t roam around a de facto pedestrianized space and we just called a spade a spade?

Twitter avatar for @betterstreetsai
AI-generated street transformations @betterstreetsai
Pike Place Market (Seattle, Washington)
Image
Image
9:01 PM ∙ Jul 30, 2022
2,820Likes242Retweets

 In an interview with Bloomberg—whose namesake was mayor of a city with a lot of traffic!—Katz said he’d learned of visual AI’s political power through his admin work for @betterstreetsai. Local lawmakers had reached out to him to inspire future street designs in their cities.

“Council members and urban planners from all over the country seem to be very inspired by the images,” Katz said. “I think this is how it will lead to change: people with real decision making power being influenced and inspired by these images.”

I sense an impending dyad! That a technology (in this case, image-generation AI) developed under hypercapitalist conditions can push for public management of common spaces, rather than their automotive privatization, which could let us say toodaloo! to neoliberal urban design!! But before we celebrate that as some sort of liberatory outcome, we should consider how many capitalist rituals necessitating “imagination”—the idea of the “creative,” the imperative to “love your job,” and more—are really just invitations to lie. Like, even at best, an invitation for a “free response” that’s really multiple choice. 

The invitation to lie goes far! For one this tweet, which made me giggle: 

Twitter avatar for @roastmalone_
stoned cold fox @roastmalone_
cover letters are so weird like bro why do I need to write you some fan fiction about working for you
8:38 PM ∙ Aug 26, 2022
394,319Likes45,482Retweets

But also college applications (to colleges that sit on so much money but make you take out loans), lying about liking your job to your boss, inventing reasons to use sick days, saying “ok great!” when you really mean “I want to bash your skull in!” etc. 

Which are cultures no doubt underpinning the tech world too! Hello “listening and learning and growing.” gm :) 

So two questions: How much of imagining alternatives like @betterstreetsai is predicated on capitalist traditions of lying, hemmed in by the kinds of visions that are made available to us now? (Is everything a lie? Like, not just an original sin, but a bajillion tiny sins?) And secondly, are we lying to ourselves—a pedestrianized Bostonian riverfront that looks a little like Lyon!—to avoid the really hard thing, which is to overthrow the governments that make such a vision impossible?

And naming DALL-E after Dalí feels a little fascist and uncreative and on the nose. Whoever named that clearly didn’t have the best imagination and just mixed Pixar with pro-Francisco Franco surrealism!! (Which wouldn’t be too far off for Disney anyway…)

But get over lying being a sin, baby! Sometimes lying can be so much fun, or even liberatory in its own right. 

Another Twitter account: Competent Mayor Bill de Blasio, which, over the course of the erstwhile NYC mayor’s time in office, would post the opposite of whatever shitty thing de Blasio had actually announced. 

So, for instance, real bike lanes! 

Twitter avatar for @GoodNYCMayor
Competent Mayor Bill de Blasio (Archive) @GoodNYCMayor
Today I’m pleased to announce that after quick-building over 300 miles of bike lanes this year to get our city moving safely, @NYC_DOT is starting the process of making them all truly protected. Jersey barrier teams will be out throughout the winter solidifying our bike network.
Image
1:35 PM ∙ Oct 16, 2020
237Likes21Retweets

Or beautiful parks along the Manhattan side of the East River: 

Twitter avatar for @GoodNYCMayor
Competent Mayor Bill de Blasio (Archive) @GoodNYCMayor
Beautiful! This is my vision for the East River once we tear down the FDR.
Twitter avatar for @AmericanFietser
American Fietser @AmericanFietser
I can't stop looking at this image. It's what every waterfront worldwide should look like. Cars have no business next to water...ever. 😍 Utrecht 🇳🇱 📸-@Ramoncp72 https://t.co/jis9h7FAQX
4:43 PM ∙ May 9, 2021
121Likes9Retweets

Hell, even draconian traffic mitigation measures to reduce heat: 

Twitter avatar for @GoodNYCMayor
Competent Mayor Bill de Blasio (Archive) @GoodNYCMayor
Vehicles contribute immensely to the effective heat on our streets. We have reduced all bridges and highways to one lane to minimize traffic and discourage driving. Take transit, bike (with lots of water), work from home, and if you absolutely must use a car, expect delays.
Twitter avatar for @NYCMayorsOffice
NYC Mayor's Office @NYCMayorsOffice
An Excessive Heat Warning is in effect for #NYC as of 11AM. Heat indices of 105 degrees are expected. Cooling centers are OPEN. Find more information at https://t.co/Vhmf24fOLF. https://t.co/qf1C6C0iB5
1:54 PM ∙ Aug 11, 2021
276Likes29Retweets

Across the board, all lies, but also proving how much power individual politicians do hold. What if de Blasio had just gone ahead and announced these things? Sure, checks and balances blah blah blah, but the account raises the question of much progressive momentum de Blasio could have thrown around through simple mot et parole, but didn’t.

Both these accounts and their respective/simultaneous lies—in the forms of distraction and a measure of freedom/accountability—find a home on the same platform, namely Twitter. It’s hard to guarantee we’re doing the latter form of lying and not the former, especially when the channels for disseminating these messages reward virality, which is itself largely prone to sensationalism over substance. And expecting the accounts’ creators and viewers to be ~*honest*~ about their intentions (a passion project rather than a civilizational treatise, for instance, or pure entertainment) seems unlikely too. 

If we’re all lying, we might as well have a great time doing it :) 

Thank you DALL-E! Enjoy your Sunday!

Divine Innovation is a somewhat cheeky newsletter on spirituality and technology. Published once every three weeks, it’s written by Adam Willems and edited by Vanessa Rae Haughton. Find the full archive here.

Share
Comments
Top
New
Community

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Adam Willems
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing